The SandPiper

Our stay in Greenport at the Sandpiper was wonderful! Location was perfect: easy walk into town and to the ferry to shelter island. Ten out of ten!

Charming and just right! Our stay was delightful at the SandPiper. It was a perfect size for our family and the host thought of everything to make sure we were comfortable. Greenport is a gem and even though it rained while we were here, we enjoyed taking the ferry over to Shelter Island and Sag Harbor. Great location on a quiet street. (And close to the ferry to CT.) Highly recommended!

Winter get away in Greenport Lovely 2 night getaway for my birthday. And opportunity to see where ancestors once lived. We had a great time and the waitress in restaurant knew my family. Just wonderful town and sweet apartment.

Great place to stay My friends and I stayed here for a night after a wedding. It was the perfect place to stay after a long day. Host was kind and helpful with anything I needed!

Easy Stay My stay in Greenport was very comfortable. Very convenient to Shelter Island Ferry...walking distance. The place was very clean and well stocked with all things needed. There was a lot of light coming in to the front bedroom. I did bring a sleep mask so not a problem for me. Very pleased with my whole experience and will come again.

Apt great, manager not We really appreciated the space, organization, and cleanliness of the apartment overall! The location was very convenient and walkable, but street noise in the early morning was not ideal (train whistles, loud trucks, and motorcycles starting around 6am). My friend who used earplugs had no problem, but I can't use them to sleep and it did impact my sleep, so just something to consider based on your own preferences. While the apartment overall was very very clean, there was spoiled milk and creamer in the fridge when we arrived and no liner in the garbage can - which certainly matters when you are expected to empty the garbage yourself. Most importantly, the owner was not great at communicating. I emailed him questions about access twice and he did not write back. When I wrote with another question that he did not like, he sent a long, angry email basically said we shouldn't be staying in a short term rental because our standards were too high. Between the two of us, my friend and I have stayed in short term rentals over 100 times and we definitely know that while every request might not be granted, our questions about access were not at all unreasonable. I actually think this is a great spot, as long as everything goes smoothly (and you have earplugs and are comfortable throwing away spoiled milk). However, I would not rent again from this host because I'd be too worried about what might happen if there were any problems.