The Oak & Anchor Hotel

What a totally disappointing dining experience. Ordered the Moroccan chicken dish, it was roast chicken breast sitting atop couscous with no seasoning whatsoever on the chicken, thank god for salt! Partner had the confit duck which he enjoyed. What he didn't enjoy was the Margarita he ordered which was devoid of any alcohol. I don't particularly like tequila so had a sip and there was no hint of tequila in the drink. Sent it back to the bar commenting that 'I think they may have forgotten the tequila' heard nothing back until we went to pay and got told by the bar woman that she had not fogotten to put tequila in it and that mayb we were just not use to that particular tequila. Her attitude was appalling. Said she tried every cocktail she made before pouring, well actually she didn't try the ones she had just served up and most deffinately could not have tried ours or she would hopefully have owned up to her mistake. So over the next 20 days that we are in Port Fairy, and with plenty of other eateries to chose from, we won't be back to the Sidro.

First impressions were of a beautiful renovation of an old building. Quite quickly became apparent it was all style over substance. The set up is basically rooms over a pub/bar and staff are to be found behind the bar which appears to be their main focus. Room; It's open plan loo and not a great arrangement when both of us in room at same time. Wet room shower is very difficult to keep the shower water from splashing all over bathroom floor and making the bathroom one big wet room. No cupboards just a rail which once a few clothes pulled out of the cases looks messy. Steps between bathroom and bed need to be remembered if having pee at night. Service; asked for a booking in restaurant that evening and told fully booked try elsewhere. No offering at time of booking would we like to reserve restaurant or warning that tables not kept for hotel guests. Breakfast; literally laid out on the bar counter with limited choice. Asked for a second cup of coffee twice and waited 15 min before giving up waiting Bed comfortable and room clean. Location central but no interesting views. By far the most expensive stay on the Great Ocean Road comparable to central Sydney/Melbourne 5* Hotel prices yet in the end just a fancy styled room over a pub with strange service.

We just stayed two nights in this wonderful, thoughtful renovated old pub. Maybe one of the nicest places we have ever stayed in Australia so far. The character and charm of this historic place was protected while all the modern amenities were implemented as well. We also ate in the pub. It was absolutely delicious. Loved the interpretation of the ice berg salad. Staff is extremely friendly and professional. We had a very warm welcome. Great job to the owners of this place.